This last days I have been thinking some about how next gen AOP implementations may look like in say 4 years from now in the Java landscape.
As you may known, 5 years ago AspectJ was not based on bytecode manipulation but was based on source code transformation.
As of today, full blown AOP like AspectJ and JBoss AOP are usually build on top of really heavy bytecode manipulation, while more lightweight approach like Spring AOP are build on top of proxy (which under the hood can use bytecode generation technology ie JDK or CGlib proxy).
In the next few days we will start spreading the prototype implementation of AOP support in JRockit JVM which allows to implement all of the AOP interceptions features without even touching the bytecode but with a more abstracted subscription based API. If you missed the dev2dev series you can read more about it there.
This technology is definitely a breakthrough in the field, but does not address the introduction/mixin features ie capability to add method / field / annotation / change the object hierarchy of the object model in a crosscutting manner.
This means that f.e. to implement AspectJ as it is on top of the new JVM based technology we need to wether
- remove the feature from AspectJ - this is dumb as introduction are an important part of AOP
- do that in the VM - well, perhaps but unlikely from my perspective as it would mean changing the Java language itself else ones would not be able to call the introduced members from regular code
- use an hybrid bytecode / VM based AOP approach - why not but it looks a lot like going back to the old bytecode based implementation complexity
- do it in another way!
My thoughts on that is that we will likely do it in another way - and perhaps going back to source code transformation. This year Sun' folks presented the Jackpot project at JavaOne - which is sort of a rule driven source transformation engine. If that ones goes mainstream somewhere with Java 7, ones will have a fairly great technology set to rethink the way we implement AOP in Java, mixing nextgen APT (that will expose the full AST), Jackpot and JVM weaving.
Posts
